Poor Things: 'I don't mind they erased Glasgow from dad's book' (2024)

  • Published

Poor Things: 'I don't mind they erased Glasgow from dad's book' (1)Image source, Searchlight Pictures

By Pauline McLean

BBC Scotland arts correspondent

The film Poor Things has already won awards and been tipped for Oscar success despite only opening in cinemas around the UK this weekend.

Based on a 1992 novel by Scots artist and writer Alasdair Gray, it's the fantastical tale of a woman who takes her own life and is revived by a Victorian surgeon who replaces her brain with that of her unborn child.

Filmmaker Yorgos Lanthimos was blown away by the book which he first read in 2009.

"I completely fell in love with Bella Baxter - and it was obvious to me that somehow I had to bring her to life.

"I was surprised no one had made a film version."

In fact, there was a film version - written by Alasdair Gray and Sandy Johnson - just two years after the book was published. They envisaged a cast which included Robert Carlisle and Helena Bonham Carter but it was a project which didn't get off the ground.

Lanthimos travelled to Glasgow in 2011 to meet Alasdair Gray, and was taken on a tour of the places mentioned in the book. A year later, Lanthimos acquired the film rights.

A decade later, with a screenplay by Tony McNamara, the film began shooting on a set in Hungary, the Glasgow locations replaced with futuristic versions of Paris, Lisbon and London.

Image source, Searchlight pictures

But Alasdair Gray's son Andrew, who looks after the Gray estate, disagrees. He believes the production and its entire cast and crew treated the book with respect.

"When I met the cast, a lot of people had read the book so I was very impressed with that.

"My father didn't set any pre-conditions when he met Yorgos. The contract was drawn up, probably around 2012 and he was aware and in agreement with the circ*mstances of it.

"He wasn't a film director. He was happy for someone else to take on his work."

Image source, Reuters

There's also more than a hint of Gray in the character of Baxter, played by Willem Dafoe.

The Frankenstein patchwork of his face has echoes of Alasdair Gray's chiselled artwork and he uses the same gentle accent and singsong voice as Gray himself.

"I listened to tapes of Alasdair Gray," he said," and even though I wasn't trying to copy that accent I liked how he spoke and he had a wicked sense of humour and I think he put a lot of himself into the character of Baxter."

The film has been garnering awards since it first won the top prize at the Venice Film Festival in September.

Last week it won two Golden Globes and is now being tipped for Bafta and Oscar success.

"It's very much like a fairy tale for me," says Andrew Gray, who's seen the film seven times, including a special screening at the Glasgow Film Theatre and another in his neighbourhood cinema in Connecticut where he's lived for the last 30 years.

"It's not often you get invited to red carpet events, I know the experience is temporary but it's been good fun."

Gray, who died in 2019 at the age of 85 was one of Scotland's greatest artists and writers.

His first novel Lanark, published in 1981, is widely regarded as a landmark publication, responsible for a renaissance in Scottish writing.

One of his artworks, in private hands since it was created in the 1950s, sold at auction last week for a record £42,700.

Andrew Gray believes it's long overdue attention.

"I think Alasdair has been neglected over the years and I'm hoping this will being more international attention to his work," he said.

"The limelight that this film has shared onto his work is certainly going to promote his writing and his art. It's going to bring new readers back to the book."

And that's the hope they have at the National Library of Scotland which holds his literary archive.

It includes handwritten notes, manuscripts, artworks and letters. There are three early versions of Poor Creatures, which would go on to become Poor Things.

In the correspondence is a letter from Gray to Yorgos Lanthimos after his visit to Glasgow, wishing him the best for his film adaptation.

Colin McIlroy, curator of modern literary manuscripts said: "There are hundreds and hundreds of boxes.

"And it covers pretty much the working process for almost all of his written output: novels, short stories, dramas, radio adaptations, film scripts, diaries, and correspondence."

Image source, NAtiona Library of Scotland

Some of the archive is available for consultation in the library's reading rooms but with 200 boxes, spanning a career of almost seven decades, the library is currently fundraising for a full time cataloguer.

Chris Cassells, head of archives and manuscript collections at the library said: "This is a collection of international significance - one of the biggest literary archives we have.

"We would very much hope that, given the amount of attention the film has received, given that it's really put Alasdair's name in the spotlight internationally, that people will watch the film before reading the book.

"And then they'll read other books and explore perhaps further into the hinterlands of Scottish literature."

Related Topics

  • Literature
  • Film
  • Glasgow

More on this story

  • Scots author Alasdair Gray dies aged 85

    • Published

      29 December 2019

  • Gray on books, Yes vote and depression

    • Published

      28 March 2014

  • Alasdair Gray on his 'unfinished work'

    • Published

      29 November 2016

Poor Things: 'I don't mind they erased Glasgow from dad's book' (2024)

FAQs

Why is Poor Things so controversial? ›

The film's themes have led to backlash, with some claiming that the fact it has a male director, and therefore a male gaze, makes it sexist. There have also been accusations that the nudity is exploitative and that, because Bella has the brain of a child, there are consent issues at play.

How does Poor Things differ from the book? ›

The movie is presented mostly from Bella's point of view, with occasional cuts back to Godwin and Max McCandles (his renamed apprentice, played by Ramy Youssef) in the London house. The book has a more complex, nested structure.

Is Poor Things based off a book? ›

The Oscar-nominated film is based on a 1992 book by the prolific Scotsman Alasdair Gray. Beloved by writers, “that's not the same as being widely read,” says one of them.

How does the novel Poor Things end? ›

In the novel, Bella also ends up with Archibald, but the novel ends with Godwin's death instead. The book also features two additional sections: a letter from Bella to her future descendants about errors she finds in Archibald's version of their story and an appendix from author Gray.

How disturbing is Poor Things? ›

Content warning: the film depicts scenes of blood, interior organs, dead corpses, graphic surgery, suicide, sexual assault, prostitution and nudity. The film “Poor Things” got some of the most mixed reviews that I have ever seen, making it arguably one of the most impactful films of the year.

Is Poor Things worth reading? ›

Poor Things is an intriguing book well worth the read. Its unique narrative style and thought-provoking themes make it a rewarding literary experience.

Was Poor Things a flop? ›

Poor Things surpasses $100 million globally, becoming director Yorgos Lanthimos' highest-grossing film. The $35 million-budgeted film is the fourth-highest-grossing Best Picture nominee at the 2024 Oscars. Despite its smaller budget, Poor Things received 11 Oscar nominations, solidifying its success.

What happened to God's face in Poor Things? ›

Called “God” by Bella, Godwin bears grotesque scars on his face and body resulting from his childhood experience as the subject of his father's deranged scientific curiosity – an experience that failed to stymie his own rather baroque quest for empirical facts.

Is Poor Things based on a true story? ›

PSA: Poor Things is not a true story.

How many Oscars did Poor Things win? ›

It was also nominated for thirteen Critics' Choice Awards (including Best Picture), with Stone winning for Best Actress, eleven BAFTA Awards (including Best Film), winning for five awards, including Best Actress in a Leading Role for Stone, and eleven Academy Awards, winning for four awards.

How accurate is Poor Things to the book? ›

The original Alasdair Gray novel laid the groundwork for this 2023 film adaptation, but there are a few key differences some might not know upon first glance. Poor Things works well on its own merit as a film, and yet it still retains the secret ingredient of the book.

Is Poor Things set in Glasgow? ›

Victorian era Glasgow is the main setting for Poor Things, with many real locations mentioned in the novel. Bella's home is 18 Park Circus, a real address near Kelvingrove Park, which is illustrated with maps and drawings in the book.

What happened to Willem Dafoe's face in Poor Things? ›

Dafoe stars as the disfigured mad scientist Dr. Godwin Baxter, whose face was maimed by his surgeon father when he was younger. In the film, Dr. Baxter decides to reanimate a woman's corpse by placing her brain with the brain of an unborn child.

Does Bella get pregnant in Poor Things? ›

Max falls in love with Godwin's ward, Bella, a childlike young woman. Godwin reveals that Bella's body is that of a woman who was pregnant and killed herself by leaping off a bridge.

What is the deeper meaning behind Poor Things? ›

Poor Things is a film about innocence, about discovery, about human nature. It makes us question the way we view things, the way we censor behaviour, the way we impose societal norms upon each other, and how seeing those norms disregarded can be both disturbing and exhilarating.

Why do critics like Poor Things? ›

Poor Things is a film about innocence, about discovery, about human nature. It makes us question the way we view things, the way we censor behaviour, the way we impose societal norms upon each other, and how seeing those norms disregarded can be both disturbing and exhilarating.

What is the point of Poor Things? ›

Poor Things follows Bella on her journey from a Frankenstein-esque creation to a full-fledged woman as she learns the ways of the world through various experiences that change her and help her understand the complexities of her existence.

What is the main theme of Poor Things? ›

Poor Things Explained

The most obvious theme in the film is the subjugation women are forced to endure from men. Characters like Duncan are attracted to Bella because of her looks and her willingness to go along with whatever they say. Then, once Bella develops a mind of her own, Duncan becomes insecure and angry.

Is Poor Things a satire? ›

Poor Things is a scabrous satire of the stifling rationalism and oppressive hierarchies of class, imperialism, and gender that propelled Glasgow's rapid industrialization in the nineteenth century.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Corie Satterfield

Last Updated:

Views: 6266

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Corie Satterfield

Birthday: 1992-08-19

Address: 850 Benjamin Bridge, Dickinsonchester, CO 68572-0542

Phone: +26813599986666

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Table tennis, Soapmaking, Flower arranging, amateur radio, Rock climbing, scrapbook, Horseback riding

Introduction: My name is Corie Satterfield, I am a fancy, perfect, spotless, quaint, fantastic, funny, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.